Should You Visit Utrecht Or Amsterdam? Locals Weigh In

Photo of author
Latest update:

I lived many years in Amsterdam and Utrecht and know both cities inside out. However, it may be difficult for foreign visitors to decide which of these two Dutch cities they should visit. Is it a good idea to visit Utrecht instead of Amsterdam? Therefore, I sat down with other locals to compare Utrecht with Amsterdam to help you decide which city to visit.

Amsterdam is a mesmerizing city with its rich history, beautiful canals, and vibrant atmosphere, but tourists overrun it. However, the authenticity that made Amsterdam popular is still present in Utrecht, which is less crowded, much cheaper, and a better choice to visit.

Getting a genuine, unadulterated impression of a Dutch city in Amsterdam is no longer possible. However, Utrecht is still an authentic, quaint Dutch city because it welcomes only a fraction of visitors compared to Amsterdam, and most of them are Dutchmen.

Even though Utrecht is much smaller than Amsterdam, you will get a much better impression of a quintessential Dutch city and the Dutch in Utrecht than in Amsterdam. Read on to discover seven reasons you should visit Utrecht instead of Amsterdam.

Why Should You Visit Utrecht?

The best way to compare Utrecht with Amsterdam is to look at several important aspects for foreign visitors visiting a Dutch city.

The seven reasons for foreign visitors to visit Utrecht instead of Amsterdam are:

  1. Utrecht is just as charming as Amsterdam
  2. Utrecht is not as crowded as Amsterdam
  3. Utrecht is much cheaper than Amsterdam
  4. Utrecht has fantastic terraces next to its canals
  5. Utrecht is much more compact
  6. Utrecht is easier to reach
  7. Utrecht has a beautiful shopping mall in its center

1. Utrecht Is Just As Charming As Amsterdam

What makes a Dutch city attractive is the unique blend of rich history, the aesthetic beauty of its canals and buildings, and the vibrant international atmosphere that you will find in The Netherlands. Amsterdam has all these qualities in spades and deserves its excellent reputation as a fantastic city. You can make amazing Instagram shots in Amsterdam.

However, Amsterdam is not the only mesmerizing city in The Netherlands. We are fortunate to live in a country with plenty of such towns.

Amsterdam may have many beautiful canals, but Utrecht is as enchanting as Amsterdam, with its two main canals, Oude Gracht en Nieuwe Gracht, meandering through its medieval center. The medieval Dom tower, the highest church tower in The Netherlands, dominates the center of Utrecht.

Around the Dom tower, you will find lovely authentic neighborhoods with magnificent buildings, and you can still find plenty of quiet spots in the center of Utrecht. Utrecht is simply the best-kept secret of The Netherlands.

The neighborhood around the Nieuwe Gracht is the most beautiful area in the center of Utrecht. You will find the same aesthetic architecture and canals as Amsterdam, but it will be just you and a few locals walking around.

2. Utrecht Is Not As Crowded As Amsterdam

Amsterdam’s popularity has become too much, and close to 20 million tourists visit Amsterdam yearly. That is too much for a city with about 800.000 inhabitants.

When I lived in Amsterdam, I often looked in amazement at the endless streams of foreign visitors walking through Amsterdam. However, if we went to Amsterdam’s center ourselves, we would be surrounded only by tourists because the locals avoid Amsterdam’s center due to the massive streams of tourists.

Amsterdam has become too crowded with tourists to remain authentic. Therefore, you no longer get a genuine, unadulterated impression of The Netherlands in Amsterdam. Fortunately, the authenticity that made Amsterdam so popular in the first place is still present in Utrecht. Utrecht has maintained its authenticity because it receives less than 20% of Amsterdam visitors, and most of those visitors are Dutchmen themselves.

You can find everything Amsterdam offers in Utrecht and do not need to walk around with thousands of other visitors like in Amsterdam. You can make Instagram selfies with canals in the background without waiting for other tourists or pushing them aside. You can rent a barge to tour the canals and not be on the lookout for barges all the time because there will be no traffic jams on the canals like in Amsterdam.

Utrecht is the city that Amsterdam was before it became too popular. When social distance is necessary for the new normal, a crowded city like Amsterdam will be less attractive. A quieter town like Utrecht, with peaceful parks like the Park Lepelenburg in its center, will be more appealing.

3. Utrecht Is Much Cheaper Than Amsterdam

The popularity of Amsterdam caused prices to skyrocket in Amsterdam. As a result, the costs of hotels, restaurants, and whatever is used by tourists have gone through the roof. Check out here what a 3-day trip to Amsterdam will cost you. You can save 30-50% on hotels and restaurants in Utrecht instead of Amsterdam.

When comparing both cities, the most striking example is the price of renting a barge to cruise over the canals. The best deal I could find in Utrecht was € 30 / hour, while Amsterdam’s best deals were € 150-200 / hour.

If you want to spend an afternoon on the water, that adds up quickly.

4. Utrecht Has Extremely Attractive Terraces Next To Its Canals

One of Utrecht’s most appealing aspects is its terraces and restaurants next to its canals. These terraces were used to unload cargo from ships coming to Utrecht. The unloaded trading goods were stored in the cellars under the street. The cellars have been reconstructed and are now used as restaurants and bars.

These restaurants and terraces add to the charm of Utrecht as a city. Sitting on these terraces in the sun and watching the boats and barges passing by is lovely. It brings an enchanting atmosphere to that part of the town, especially during the evenings. You can find the best terraces in Utrecht at the Oude Gracht, north of City Hall.

If you want to look at the terraces from the water, which I highly recommend, you may want to consider renting a boat from Greenjoy. You can book a barge online, activate them with your mobile phone and sail away. These barges are powered by electromotors and are easy to operate, even if you are inexperienced in steering a boat.

Check it out, and you will be glad you did. Experiencing a Dutch city from the water may be one of the best memories of your vacation.

5. Utrecht Is More Compact Than Amsterdam

Utrecht is the fourth largest city in The Netherlands and has 360.000 inhabitants, less than half of Amsterdam’s 820.000 inhabitants. However, Utrecht is much smaller and more compact than Amsterdam, making it much easier to get around in Utrecht.

Everything in Utrecht turns around the Dom tower, the highest church tower in The Netherlands, standing proudly in the city center. A canal ring encloses the quaint center of Utrecht, which was used to protect the city in the medieval period.

It is much easier to get around in Utrecht because it is more compact. Every highlight in Utrecht is within walking distance of the Dom tower, a maximum of 10-15 minutes in every direction.

That is a significant advantage compared to Amsterdam if you want to avoid public transportation as much as possible to maintain a social distance of 1,5 meters.

Walking to the Rietveld-Schröder House from the city center, one of the UNESCO World Heritage Sites in The Netherlands, will only take 15-20 minutes. The added advantage is that you will walk through parts of the town, Oudwijk, and Wilhelmina Park, which are very popular.

Take a break on a bench next to the pond in the park to enjoy the relaxed atmosphere. I lived for many years next to Wilhelmina Park and feel that it is one of the most lovely spots in Utrecht that you can find.

6. Utrecht Is Easier To Reach Than Amsterdam

Utrecht is located right in the middle of the Netherlands. The train station of Utrecht is the biggest in the country, and you can rapidly get from any other major city in The Netherlands to Utrecht by train. Utrecht is also easy to reach by car, but parking is almost impossible in and around the center.

The train station is smack in the center of Utrecht and next to the historic center. Walking from the train station to the historic center takes 5-10 minutes at most.

If you come to Utrecht by train, you may want to consider visiting the National Railway Museum. You can reach this museum by train departing from Utrecht Center.

7. Utrecht Has A Fantastic Shopping Mall In Its Center

Shopping in Utrecht is organized around a modern indoor shopping mall that was recently completely renovated.

That shopping mall in Utrecht is called ‘Hoog Catharijne’ and is located in its center. Hoog Catharijne lies next to the train station of Utrecht, making it very easy to reach. Furthermore, the main shopping area of Utrecht is on the other side of Hoog Catharijne, and this combination makes Utrecht a unique shopping city with plenty of choices.

Hoog Catharijne has recently been renovated. It is now an up-to-date and modern shopping mall. I like Hoog Catharijne because it is all indoors, but it does not feel like that. Hoog Catharijne is not as huge as The Mall of The Netherlands in Leidschendam, but still large. On a rainy day, you can come in by train and shop in Hoog Catharijne without getting out in the rain.

You can check out the website of Hoog Catharijne here if you want to find out in advance if your favorite brands are present there.

Map Of 10 Best Tourist Highlights in Utrecht

I prepared a map of the ten best tourist highlights (blue) and recommended hotels (red) in Utrecht.


Recommended Hotels In Utrecht

The best hotel in Utrecht is the Grand Hotel Karel V, located in the medieval center of Utrecht and 5-10 minutes from the central railway station.

There are several more budget-friendly modern hotels near the railway station if you would still like to hop on a train and visit Amsterdam. I recommend looking for a hotel on the eastern side of the central railway station to avoid having to cross the station at night.

Inntel Hotels Utrecht Centre and Hampton by Hilton Utrecht Centraal Station are budget-friendly hotels with excellent customer reviews on the right side of the railway station.

Other Charming Dutch Cities

Besides Utrecht and Amsterdam, there are plenty of other quintessential Dutch cities that you could visit to experience a bustling, genuine, authentic Dutch town.

You can find reviews of these other cities through the links below.

Photo of author
Pim Tijburg
Pim has lived his entire life in The Netherlands and he enjoys writing this blog about his home country. His mission is to make you like The Netherlands as much as he does.